Crime Writers On...Esoteric

An unofficial Crime Writers On...online resource and community site.

The Yogurt Shop Murders

a Series

Produced by: HBO Documentary Films

Sept. 1, 2025

Episode #664

CWO Episode Description:

In 1991, four teenage girls were found murdered inside a frozen yogurt store in Austin, Texas. The building had been set on fire, and the crime scene was compromised by the blaze. With no clear motive and little physical evidence, investigators struggled to make sense of what had happened. Years later, after coercive police interviews, a group of men pointed fingers at each other about the crime. Though their stories didn’t completely match, two were convicted and one of them sent to death row. But their convictions were overturned, and new DNA evidence pointed to an unknown suspect. The case remains unresolved, leaving investigators and relatives to wonder what went wrong. From HBO Documentary Films comes “The Yogurt Shop Murders.” The series digs into the twists and turns of the homicide investigation. It also spends considerable time exploring the emotional toll the case has had on the accused, the grieving family members, and the detectives trying to get justice. OUR SPOILER-FREE REVIEWS OF "THE YOGURT SHOP MURDERS" BEGIN IN THE FINAL 13 MINUTES OF THE EPISODE. In Crime of the Week: well done.

Lara

Lara's Vote

Co-host

Sideways

Sideways
Toby

Toby's Vote

Co-host

Thumbs Up

Thumbs Up
Guest

Guest Vote

Special Guest

N/A

N/A
Kevin

Kevin's Vote

Co-host

Mild Up

Mild Up
Rebecca

Rebecca's Vote

Co-host

Thumbs Up

Thumbs Up

Total Points (0-16)

13

Back to Reviews

Community Rating of this CWO Episode

None/5 (0 ratings)

Want to rate this review?

CWOEsoteric Votes!

What did YOU think of The Yogurt Shop Murders?

Vote vote here using the same system as the CWO hosts!

Thumbs Up Thumbs Up 0
Mild Up Mild Up 0
Sideways Sideways 0
Mild Down Mild Down 0
Thumbs Down Thumbs Down 0
Total Community Votes: 0

So, did Crime Writers On...get this one right?