Crime Writers On...Esoteric

An unofficial Crime Writers On...online resource and community site.

Hands Tied

a Podcast

Produced by: iHeartPodcasts and BBC Studios

Oct. 2, 2025

Episode #673

CWO Episode Description:

True crime fan Lizz Melgar Rose found herself in the middle of her own case. In 2012, her father Jim was murdered in his Texas home while her mother Sandy was tied up and left in a closet wedged shut by a chair. But Sandy Melgar’s inability to recall details of the home invasion made police suspicious. Lizz claimed investigators never pursued other leads, including evidence of a burglary, choosing instead to believe Sandy tied her own hands behind her back and staged the crime scene. Even with no motive or evidence linking her to the brutal stabbing, prosecutors charged her with murder. iHeartPodcasts and BBC Studios present “Hands Tied.” Host Maggie Robinson Katz explores the theory that a middle-aged woman with epilepsy and arthritis could stab her husband 30 times, stay spotless, then bind herself in a closet locked from the outside. The podcast also follows Lizz’s fight to prove her mother’s innocence.

Lara

Lara's Vote

Co-host

Mild Up

Mild Up
Toby

Toby's Vote

Co-host

Mild Up

Mild Up
Guest

Guest Vote

Special Guest

N/A

N/A
Kevin

Kevin's Vote

Co-host

Mild Up

Mild Up
Rebecca

Rebecca's Vote

Co-host

Mild Up

Mild Up

Total Points (0-16)

12

Back to Reviews

Community Rating of this CWO Episode

None/5 (0 ratings)

Want to rate this review?

CWOEsoteric Votes!

What did YOU think of Hands Tied?

Vote vote here using the same system as the CWO hosts!

Thumbs Up Thumbs Up 0
Mild Up Mild Up 0
Sideways Sideways 0
Mild Down Mild Down 0
Thumbs Down Thumbs Down 0
Total Community Votes: 0

So, did Crime Writers On...get this one right?