Crime Writers On...Esoteric

An unofficial Crime Writers On...online resource and community site.

Breakdown: Three Days in May

a Podcast

Produced by: Atlanta Journal-Constitution

Sept. 29, 2025

Episode #672

CWO Episode Description:

Ashley and Albert Debelbot had just put their newborn McKenzy to bed for the first time, but hours later, they rushed the infant back to the hospital after finding a bump on her forehead. When she died, police concluded the parents harmed her and charged them with murder. Facing an overzealous prosecutor, a partial judge, and ineffective defense attorneys, the Debelbots spent twelve years in prison trying to clear their names. But a new legal team uncovered evidence suggesting McKenzy died from a prenatal injury, not a beating. Season 11 of The Atlanta Journal-Constitution’s investigative series “Breakdown: Three Days in May” looks into the Debelbots’ complicated case. Hosts Bill Rankin and Tamara Hallerman recount the investigative rush-to-judgment, the flawed trial, and the evidence pointing to a medical cause of the baby’s death—not a criminal one. In Crime of the Week: going nuts!

Lara

Lara's Vote

Co-host

Thumbs Up

Thumbs Up
Toby

Toby's Vote

Co-host

Thumbs Up

Thumbs Up
Guest

Guest Vote

Special Guest

N/A

N/A
Kevin

Kevin's Vote

Co-host

Thumbs Up

Thumbs Up
Rebecca

Rebecca's Vote

Co-host

Thumbs Up

Thumbs Up

Total Points (0-16)

16

Back to Reviews

Community Rating of this CWO Episode

None/5 (0 ratings)

Want to rate this review?

CWOEsoteric Votes!

What did YOU think of Breakdown: Three Days in May?

Vote vote here using the same system as the CWO hosts!

Thumbs Up Thumbs Up 0
Mild Up Mild Up 0
Sideways Sideways 0
Mild Down Mild Down 0
Thumbs Down Thumbs Down 0
Total Community Votes: 0

So, did Crime Writers On...get this one right?